Below is a break down of the voting in each category.
Photos of the final vote tallies are at the bottom.
I always find write in votes to be an adventure. Some make obvious sense, some are faint hopeless causes, then some, for reasons unbeknownst to anyone, can only be explained by the person who did it. Such a campain happened in the non-human/prop category, where someone spent the time to vote 359 times for Coffee. Seriously. Not watching the show in question, I googled to see if there was something special about coffee on the show, but there isnt. Its not referenced on their qikipages or the official site in any notable manner...sooo, someones hours of voting for a beverage were wasted.
Several people seemed to think because the character a HUMAN was playing wasnt human that they would vote for them. I can see how you might think thats technically right, it isnt. It was still a human playing the part. Thus why you Lost Girl fans & Supernatural fans dont see Bo or Cas listed in the write in section.
So, onto the results....
BEST NON-HUMAN CHARACTER OR PROP (bold = finalist) (vote total - red)
Gene - Fringe 291, The Impala - Supernatural 236, Doomsday Machine - Fringe 174, Dexter's knife - Dexter 58, Annies Boobs - Community 56, Brian - Family Guy 53, Fairie Tale Book - Once Upon A Time 49, The Crystals - The Secret Circle 31, The Dodge Charge - Burn Notice 22, House's cane - House 15 (write-in votes), Necklace - Lost Girl 4 (write-in votes), Tesla Gun - Warehouse 13 1 (write in vote)
BEST GUEST STAR
Genevieve Padalecki - Supernatural 726, James Marsters - Supernatural 649, Callum Blue - Smallville 121, Michael Rosenbaum - Smallville 109, John Schneider - Smallville 92, Michelle Krusiec - Community 89, Wil Wheaton - The Big Bang Theory 80, Jennifer Love Hewitt - Hot In Cleveland 64, Charisma Carpenter - Supernatural 59, Julian Richings - Supernatural 57, Katie Holmes - How I Met Your Mother 55, Levar Burton - Community 47, Alona Tal - Supernatural 41, Sarah Silverman - Childrens Hospital 40, Charisma Carpenter - Burn Notice 39, Mark Sheppard - Leverage 39, Josh Holloway - Community 35, Samantha Ferris - Supernatural 33, Charisma Carpenter - Greek 27, Michael Cerveris - Person Of Interest 26, Aly Michalka - CSI NY 23, Lea Zawada - Leverage 20, Danny Glover - Leverage 19, Sam Henning - Supernatural 18, Paul Amos - Lost Girl 1 (write in vote), Kelli Williams - Criminal Minds 1 (write in vote)
Finale - Smallville 542, The Day We Died - Fringe 194, Pilot - Once Upon A Time 113, The French Mistake - Supernatural 96, The Skank Reflex Analysis - The Big Bang Theory 66, Fire And Blood - Game Of Thrones 45, A Fistfull Of Paintballs - Community 43, Betrayal - Revenge 40, The Hot Potato Job - Leverage 38, Goodbye, Michael - The Office 37, The Descent - The Vampire Diaries 30, Meet The New Boss - Supernatural 21 (write-in votes), Its Better To Burn Out Than Fae Away - Lost Girl 16 (write-in votes), Tidal Wave - Hawaii Five-O 15, The Fix - Person Of Interest 14, Monsoon - Sanctuary 10 (write in votes), Box Cutter - Breaking Bad 6, After Hours - House 5 (write in votes), Vexed - Lost Girl 5 (write in votes), The Golden Hour - Greys Anatomy 2 (write in votes), Heart Shaped Box - Greys Anatomy 1 (write in vote), Disarm - Greys Anatomy 1 (write in vote), Emily Lake - Warehouse 13 1 (write in vote), Cops & Robbers - Castle 1 (write in vote), Demons - Castle 1 (write in vote), Knockout - Castle 1 (write in vote), Marionette - Fringe 1 (write in vote), Bombshells - House 1 (write in vote), Lauren - Criminal Minds 1 (write in vote)