For the 2nd year in a row Supernatural wins best episode. Their season 7 finale, where the Winchester boys, with help from Castiel & the demon Meg take on Leviathan head Dick Roman & kill the seasons big baddie before the fangirls worst nightmare unfolds & the boys are split up as Castiel & Dean are sent to Purgatory while Sam stands alone in a room as Crowley puts it "you are well & truly, on your own". They also managed 3rd this year. Unlike last year where there was 8 finalists, from 8 different shows, this year there was 10 finalists from only 6 different shows, as 4 of them had 2 nominees each. Along with Supernatural, Castle (2nd & 4th), Fringe (5th & 6th) & Psych (9th & 10th) all had multiple finalists. The Walking Dead & Dexter were the only shows holding down 1 spot each.
"Survival Of The Fittest" beat runner up "Undead Again" from Castle by only 27 votes. The 3rd place Supernatural episode "The Girl With The Dungeons And Dragons Tattoo" was not far behind either only 29 votes behind 2nd. The 2nd Castle contender "Linchpin" came in 4th 62 votes back and 83 votes ahead of 5th place "Brave New World Pt 1&2" from Fringe.
"Survival Of The Fittest" is the 2nd win in a row for the CW show Supernatural. Only Supernatural & Fringe managed to have finalists in back to back years.
Final vote totals
Survival Of The Fittest "Supernatural" 461
Undead Again "Castle" 434
The Girl With The Dungeons And Dragons Tattoo"Supernatural" 405
Linchpin "Castle" 343
Brave New World Pt 1&2 "Fringe" 260
The End Of All Things "Fringe" 245
Are You...? "Dexter" 150
Beside The Dying Fire "The Walking Dead" 115
Santabarbaratown "Psych" 98
Heeeeere's Lassie "Psych" 95