Much like the Supporting actor category, it was a Supernatural dominated category, with fringe making just enough noise to prevent complete domination. Mark Pellegrino takes the award, leaving another SPN guest star DJ Qualls in 2nd "Fringe" star Leonard Nimoy nabs 3rd, interrupting the potential podium sweep for SPN as Felicia Day takes 4th. All 4 of these people had the lead in this poll at 1 time, before Pellegrino took over & never looked back. With Lucifer having been queited from Sams head, will this be the last we see of Pellegrino on SPN? Hard to say, but with Mark doing so many shows, its not too hard to see him back for this award again in the near future.
Mark Pellegrino beats runner up DJ Qualls by 123 votes. Back in 3rd, Leonard Nimoy was 103 votes out of 2nd, and narrowly beats 4th place Felicia Day by only 4 votes. 5th place Wil Wheaton from "The Big Bang Theory" was 113 votes back, beating out "Fringe" guest star Rebecca Mader by 22 votes.
Mark Pellegrino wins his 1st award here, and the 1st for SPN in this category as the inagural award went to Smallville star Michael Rosenbaum..
Final vote totals
Mark Pellegrino "Supernatural" 514
DJ Qualls "Supernatural" 391
Lenoard Nimoy "Fringe" 288
Felicia Day "Supernatural" 284
Wil Wheaton "The Big Bang Theory" 171
Rebecca Mader "Fringe" 149