You have to hand it to Supernatural fans. While other shows like Castle & Arrow have dominated voting in their respective categories some years for the Best Program, actor & actress in their categories, their lack of support of recurring & guest stars on their shows is quite evident by the combined ZERO top 3 finishes in any of those categories. "Supernatural" on the other hand celebrates its 4th Recurring Actor Award with Tahmoh Penikett winning this year with 698 votes.
In 2nd was Kris Holden-Ried "Lost Girl" as the show was forced to compete for the awards offered to those with 3 to 7 appearance in the year due to the odd schedule the show had. The same for 3rd place finalist "Sherlock" star Benedict Cumberbatch who had the lead for about a day at the beginning before Penikett passed him.
In 4th was Travis Aaron Wade "Supernatural" well ahead of 5th place finisher "Arrow" actor Brandon Routh. A tie for 6th between "Person of Interest" star Enrico Colantoni & "Supernatural" star Curtis Armstrong. 8th was "Once Upon A Time" star Michael raymond James. In 9th was the other "Sherlock" star Martin Freeman. 10th place tie between David Nykl & J.R. Ramirez both of "Arrow" ahead of 12th place Kevin Alejandro also from "Arrow"
1st TAHMOH PENIKETT "Supernatural" 698
2nd KRIS HOLDEN-RIED "Lost Girl" 408
3rd BENEDICT CUMBERBATCH "Sherlock" 302
4th Travis Aaron Wade "Supernatural" 299
5th Brandon Routh "Arrow" 175
6th (tie) Curtis Armstrong "Supernatural" 157
6th (tie) Enrico Colantoni "Person Of Interest" 157
8th Michael Raymond James "Once Upon A Time" 99
9th Martin Freeman "Sherlock" 70
10th (tie) David Nykl "Arrow" 59
10th (tie) J.R. Ramirez "Arrow" 59
12th Kevin Alejandro "Arrow" 56